The Personal Consequences Of An Unethical Attorney
Last week’s post covered the Rules of Professional Conduct, for both licensed attorneys and aspiring attorneys alike. The ethical rules have much to do with whether a person will be admitted to the practice of law, and govern for the duration of an attorney’s career. The rules can also impact the personal lives of, not only attorneys, but those of families, friends, and colleagues. Unethical conduct sometimes has an even greater impact on associates than on an attorney individually.
In my time practicing law, I’ve seen the devastation stemming from unethical conduct. A case that’s garnered recent media attention is the Franklin County civil case (previously a criminal matter) against the late local attorney Paul S. Kormanik. Mr. Kormanik was once a prominent Columbus attorney, very influential and respected in the Franklin County Probate Court. During Mr. Kormanik’s 30-plus-year career, he was appointed guardian of several hundred (over 400) elderly individuals.
Ohio Revised Code § 2111.02 provides authority for a Court to declare an individual incompetent, and subsequently to appoint a guardian for that individual. Commonly referred to as “wards,” these individuals no longer possess the state of mind to care for themselves or for their financial affairs. The purpose of the court appointed guardian is to act as a non-interested party, to advocate for the ward’s best interests. Guardians have a special job, and must be sufficiently trustworthy.
Unfortunately for Mr. Kormanik’s wards, Mr. Kormanik took advantage of his position of trust and power. Prior to his death, Mr. Kormanik was indicted on multiple felony charges, ranging from theft from the elderly, to corruption. Mr. Kormanik was found guilty on a number of the charges, and Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Holbrook was to sentence Mr. Kormanik to 25 years in jail. Mr. Kormanik likely would have faced additional criminal charges over time, as more victims are discovered.
Due to his unethical behavior, Mr. Kormanik’s estate and his widow, Nancy Kormanik, now face extensive litigation. The case of Marcia Pendleton, et al. v. the Estate of Paul S. Kormanik, et al. was brought on behalf of one of Mr. Kormanik’s former wards. The case alleges various causes of action, including legal malpractice, negligence, breach of fiduciary duty, and others. The case seeks over $500,000 in damages and legal fees, and has undoubtedly made an impact on his spouse and the other surviving members of his family. The family home had been in contract for sale, but is now the subject of a lis pendens notice, clouding the property’s title and obstructing the sale. Mrs. Kormanik must also pay attorney’s fees pursuant to the ongoing litigation, to say nothing of the publicity and scorn.
While Mr. Kormanik is gone, his victims will continue to suffer his transgressions. And his widow and children are left with his shameful legacy, and to pay for his wrongdoing.











